| Both sides previous revisionPrevious revision | |
| provenance:practices:notifying_websites [2026/08/13 20:15] – Log the generic reviewer's eleven findings and their disposition; add the two JSONL-verified fold claims; derive rather than hard-code the output-file split point. Authored by Claude karel.kubicek.claude | provenance:practices:notifying_websites [2026/08/13 20:16] (current) – Record the stale-page-cache bug that made most citations render as raw keys, and the purge that fixed it. Authored by Claude karel.kubicek.claude |
|---|
| * **A table rendered with every figure in the wrong column, and no reviewer caught it.** The trend table's first row labelled its indicator with a backslash-escaped pipe — %%| Notified (''yes''\|''partial'') |%% — but a backslash is **not** a DokuWiki escape for a literal pipe. The renderer treated it as a cell separator, splitting the label in two and shifting all six percentages one column left, so the 2010–2013 figure appeared under //Denominator// and the last bucket rendered empty. Caught by parsing the live page's HTML, where that row came back as %%['Notified (yes\', 'partial)', 'empirical ∧ ethics', '21.3%', …]%% against a seven-column header. Fixed by writing the label as "''yes'' or ''partial''" and avoiding the pipe entirely. **The figures reviewer checked every number against the script and passed the page; every number was right and the table was still wrong.** Checking a wiki page means parsing the rendered HTML, not only the source — the table-cell counts of both pages are now asserted from the live HTML. | * **A table rendered with every figure in the wrong column, and no reviewer caught it.** The trend table's first row labelled its indicator with a backslash-escaped pipe — %%| Notified (''yes''\|''partial'') |%% — but a backslash is **not** a DokuWiki escape for a literal pipe. The renderer treated it as a cell separator, splitting the label in two and shifting all six percentages one column left, so the 2010–2013 figure appeared under //Denominator// and the last bucket rendered empty. Caught by parsing the live page's HTML, where that row came back as %%['Notified (yes\', 'partial)', 'empirical ∧ ethics', '21.3%', …]%% against a seven-column header. Fixed by writing the label as "''yes'' or ''partial''" and avoiding the pipe entirely. **The figures reviewer checked every number against the script and passed the page; every number was right and the table was still wrong.** Checking a wiki page means parsing the rendered HTML, not only the source — the table-cell counts of both pages are now asserted from the live HTML. |
| * **The downloadable code was verified end to end.** ''curl'' on ''/_export/code/practices/notifying_websites?codeblock=0'' → ''python3 -m py_compile'' → an actual run against ''ethz.ch''. What a reader downloads from the page compiles and works. Worth doing because the code block on the page is a transcribed copy with em-dashes substituted for ASCII, and a substitution inside a string literal would have broken it silently. | * **The downloadable code was verified end to end.** ''curl'' on ''/_export/code/practices/notifying_websites?codeblock=0'' → ''python3 -m py_compile'' → an actual run against ''ethz.ch''. What a reader downloads from the page compiles and works. Worth doing because the code block on the page is a transcribed copy with em-dashes substituted for ASCII, and a substitution inside a string literal would have broken it silently. |
| | * **A stale page cache made most citations render as raw keys, and it survived four reviewers and every verification pass above.** After the bibliography was extended and the pages saved, ''https://measuretheweb.org/practices/notifying_websites'' rendered ''[lone2022_sav]'', ''[utz2023_comparing]'', ''[stock2018_didnt]'' and most others as literal bracketed keys, while the two pre-existing keys resolved normally. Nothing was wrong with the source, the bibliography or the keys — DokuWiki was serving a cached render made before the bibliography grew. Fixed by requesting each page once with ''&purge=true''; both then rendered 218 and 98 resolved citations with zero raw keys left. **Add a purge to the end of any run that touches ''literature:bibliography'', and re-check the rendered page after purging rather than before.** The earlier checks in this section counted ''bibtex_citekey'' markers and found 38 on a page with ~60 citations, which should have been the tell and was not. |
| * All eight internal links (''Artifacts'', ''Design:Website selection'', ''Literature:Corpus'', ''Practices:Ethics'', ''Practices:Legal enforcement'', ''Practices:Public relations'', ''Statistics:Hypothesis testing'', ''Statistics:Pvalue corrections'') fetched 200 with real content — no red links. ''?do=sitemap'' is cached and still listed the new page as missing, as expected. | * All eight internal links (''Artifacts'', ''Design:Website selection'', ''Literature:Corpus'', ''Practices:Ethics'', ''Practices:Legal enforcement'', ''Practices:Public relations'', ''Statistics:Hypothesis testing'', ''Statistics:Pvalue corrections'') fetched 200 with real content — no red links. ''?do=sitemap'' is cached and still listed the new page as missing, as expected. |
| |
