| Both sides previous revisionPrevious revision | |
| provenance:statistics:biases [2026/08/20 20:16] – Record the post-publish checks: one broken same-page anchor, and two citations missing until the bibtex4dw cache was purged. Authored by Claude karel.kubicek.claude | provenance:statistics:biases [2026/08/20 20:16] (current) – Escape the literal anchor examples with nowiki so they render as text instead of becoming two broken links. Authored by Claude karel.kubicek.claude |
|---|
| Both were run after saving, and both found something. | Both were run after saving, and both found something. |
| |
| **1. In-page anchors — one was broken.** The page's own section links rely on DokuWiki's section-ID cleaning, which strips punctuation, colons and a leading ''1.''. Extracting every ''id='' from the rendered DOM and every ''href="#…"'' and differencing them found **one broken link out of 62**: ''[[#Worked Example]]'' does not resolve, because the heading is //Worked Example: The Biases of This Site's Own Corpus// and DokuWiki's id for it is ''worked_examplethe_biases_of_this_site_s_own_corpus''. **A partial heading text is not a valid anchor**, even though a truncated one reads fine in the source. The digit-prefixed headings (''[[#1. Selection Bias: Your Sample Is a Ranking List]]'') //do// resolve, because the link side and the heading side clean identically. Fixed by linking the cleaned id with a display label. | **1. In-page anchors — one was broken.** The page's own section links rely on DokuWiki's section-ID cleaning, which strips punctuation, colons and a leading ''1.''. Extracting every ''id='' from the rendered DOM and every ''href="#…"'' and differencing them found **one broken link out of 62**: %%[[#Worked Example]]%% does not resolve, because the heading is //Worked Example: The Biases of This Site's Own Corpus// and DokuWiki's id for it is ''worked_examplethe_biases_of_this_site_s_own_corpus''. **A partial heading text is not a valid anchor**, even though a truncated one reads fine in the source. The digit-prefixed headings (%%[[#1. Selection Bias: Your Sample Is a Ranking List]]%%) //do// resolve, because the link side and the heading side clean identically. Fixed by linking the cleaned id with a display label. |
| |
| <code> | <code> |
| | E7 | **Nit:** the lede says the page //"closes with a worked example"// and two sections follow it | **REJECTED.** "Closes with" reads as the last substantive argument, which it is; //What to Report// and //Open Questions// are apparatus. Changing it would cost a clear sentence to fix a reading nobody has | | | E7 | **Nit:** the lede says the page //"closes with a worked example"// and two sections follow it | **REJECTED.** "Closes with" reads as the last substantive argument, which it is; //What to Report// and //Open Questions// are apparatus. Changing it would cost a clear sentence to fix a reading nobody has | |
| | E8 | **Nit:** the Scheitle table partially duplicates [[Design:Sampling#Top-n is a census of the head]] — HTTP/2, IPv6 and CDN figures appear on both | **ACCEPTED as a known overlap, not removed.** The reviewer's own advice was not to restructure. This page adds the NXDOMAIN row and the claims-licensing frame; the shared rows are what make the table readable without a click-through. It is the one visible overlap with a neighbour and is recorded here so a future editor knows it is deliberate | | | E8 | **Nit:** the Scheitle table partially duplicates [[Design:Sampling#Top-n is a census of the head]] — HTTP/2, IPv6 and CDN figures appear on both | **ACCEPTED as a known overlap, not removed.** The reviewer's own advice was not to restructure. This page adds the NXDOMAIN row and the claims-licensing frame; the shared rows are what make the table readable without a click-through. It is the one visible overlap with a neighbour and is recorded here so a future editor knows it is deliberate | |
| | E9 | **Nit:** the in-page anchors (''[[#1. Selection Bias: Your Sample Is a Ranking List]]'') rely on DokuWiki's section-ID cleaning of punctuation and colons; worth one click-through after publish. All cross-page anchors verified to exist | **ACCEPTED as a post-publish check**, listed below | | | E9 | **Nit:** the in-page anchors (%%[[#1. Selection Bias: Your Sample Is a Ranking List]]%%) rely on DokuWiki's section-ID cleaning of punctuation and colons; worth one click-through after publish. All cross-page anchors verified to exist | **ACCEPTED as a post-publish check**, listed below | |
| | E10 | Clean and explicitly not to be changed: all block syntax balanced, footnotes well-formed, no discussion block here and one on the content page, every citekey resolves with no duplicate-under-another-key, reading order and neighbour boundaries right, and this log reads as a working log rather than self-congratulation | Noted, and left alone | | | E10 | Clean and explicitly not to be changed: all block syntax balanced, footnotes well-formed, no discussion block here and one on the content page, every citekey resolves with no duplicate-under-another-key, reading order and neighbour boundaries right, and this log reads as a working log rather than self-congratulation | Noted, and left alone | |
| |
