User Tools

Site Tools


provenance:design:website_selection

Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revisionPrevious revision
Next revision
Previous revision
provenance:design:website_selection [2026/09/03 20:47] – Section 13.3.1: publishing the audit changed what it measures (16 self-inflicted SUSPECT); code blocks now stripped and provenance hits listed rather than failed, with the cost stated. Refresh the run counts and the audit output. Authored by Claude karel.kubicek.claudeprovenance:design:website_selection [2026/09/17 08:14] (current) – Record root Artifacts link repair; Authored by Claude karel.kubicek.claude
Line 235: Line 235:
 ^ Finding ^ Verdict ^ ^ Finding ^ Verdict ^
 | Page said "Tranco's **methodology** still says CC BY-SA 4.0". Live methodology HTML has no CC BY/CC BY-SA string. | **Accepted.** The licence line is on Tranco's **homepage**, not the methodology page. Content, [[programming:tranco]] and [[design:website_classification]] now say homepage vs methodology vs Google CC BY 4.0. | | Page said "Tranco's **methodology** still says CC BY-SA 4.0". Live methodology HTML has no CC BY/CC BY-SA string. | **Accepted.** The licence line is on Tranco's **homepage**, not the methodology page. Content, [[programming:tranco]] and [[design:website_classification]] now say homepage vs methodology vs Google CC BY 4.0. |
-| Tranco 46W9X, Farsight paragraph, Alexa Wayback, Umbrella hostnames + TLD file 10,905, Majestic, CrUX CC BY 4.0, Radar 403, Quantcast redirect, SecRank, Farsight not in providers enum, ''gstatic.com'' rank 3, ''compare_ranks.py --wiki'' | Confirmed 2026-08-27. |+| Tranco 46W9X, Farsight paragraph, Alexa Wayback, Umbrella hostnames + TLD file 10,905, Majestic, CrUX CC BY 4.0, Radar 403, Quantcast redirect, SecRank, Farsight not in providers enum, ''gstatic.com'' rank 3, ''compare_ranks.py %%--wiki%%'' | Confirmed 2026-08-27. |
  
 === Pass 4 — generic, no checklist === === Pass 4 — generic, no checklist ===
Line 507: Line 507:
  
 ==== 13.5 Its unedited output ==== ==== 13.5 Its unedited output ====
 +
 +**Read the unit count as "as of a revision", and the ''SUSPECT'' count as the claim.** This is the real, unedited run against the wiki as it stood immediately before this section was last saved. Re-run it now and the unit count will be **higher**, because this section is itself part of the input and every save adds sentences that pair Alexa with 2023 (§13.3.1). That is a fixed point nobody can publish their way out of: the output block can never be a run that includes the page carrying it.
 +
 +So the published claim is the **invariant, not the tally**: ''SUSPECT'' is **0 on content pages** in every run of this sitting — before the section existed (18 units), after it was first published (37), and after the revision that added §13.3.1 (39). The committed ''scripts/alexa_date_audit-output.txt'' is regenerated after each save and will disagree with the block below in its counts, by design.
  
 <code> <code>
Line 645: Line 649:
 Fixed in **three saves**, the second and third prompted by reviewers: Fixed in **three saves**, the second and third prompted by reviewers:
  
-^ Rev ^ ''--if-rev'' ^ What changed ^+^ Rev ^ ''%%--if-rev%%'' ^ What changed ^
 | 1788465991 | 1787798449 | Sentence names **1 August 2023**. Footnote states that the table's 1-January rows bracket the swap rather than dating it, quotes Tranco's front page for the date, and separates Tranco's date from Amazon's — ''alexa.com'' 1 May 2022, APIs 15 December 2022, eight months earlier. | | 1788465991 | 1787798449 | Sentence names **1 August 2023**. Footnote states that the table's 1-January rows bracket the swap rather than dating it, quotes Tranco's front page for the date, and separates Tranco's date from Amazon's — ''alexa.com'' 1 May 2022, APIs 15 December 2022, eight months earlier. |
 | 1788467004 | 1788465991 | The external-currency reviewer queried an endpoint nobody had: ''api/lists/date/20230731'' returns list **''W9ZN9''**, ''providers: [alexa, umbrella, majestic, farsight]'', ''listPrefix: full''. The next day's ''25299'' is ''[crux, farsight, majestic, radar, umbrella]'' at ''listPrefix: 1000000''. Both rows added to the table, so the swap is now **two consecutive list ids one day apart** rather than a bracket — a sharper version of the point the section exists to make. Re-verified before saving, with 30 July (''99P42'', pre-swap) and 2 August (''8289V'', post-swap) as controls. | | 1788467004 | 1788465991 | The external-currency reviewer queried an endpoint nobody had: ''api/lists/date/20230731'' returns list **''W9ZN9''**, ''providers: [alexa, umbrella, majestic, farsight]'', ''listPrefix: full''. The next day's ''25299'' is ''[crux, farsight, majestic, radar, umbrella]'' at ''listPrefix: 1000000''. Both rows added to the table, so the swap is now **two consecutive list ids one day apart** rather than a bracket — a sharper version of the point the section exists to make. Re-verified before saving, with 30 July (''99P42'', pre-swap) and 2 August (''8289V'', post-swap) as controls. |
Line 717: Line 721:
 | Re-read all 37 units of the post-publication run by hand, including the 11 ''provenance-note'', 9 ''beyond-window'' and 1 ''corpus-slug''. | All correct; no content page dates Alexa's retirement to 2023. | | Re-read all 37 units of the post-publication run by hand, including the 11 ''provenance-note'', 9 ''beyond-window'' and 1 ''corpus-slug''. | All correct; no content page dates Alexa's retirement to 2023. |
 | Re-ran the 10-mutation suite after the scope change. | All 10 behave; the fixtures live in a shell script, and the mutation is written into the page //body//, so block-stripping does not blunt the test. | | Re-ran the 10-mutation suite after the scope change. | All 10 behave; the fixtures live in a shell script, and the mutation is written into the page //body//, so block-stripping does not blunt the test. |
 +| Re-ran the audit once more after saving §13.3.1: **39 units, 0 SUSPECT**, 12 ''provenance-note'', 1 ''corpus-slug'', 9 ''beyond-window''. Every unit added since the previous run is this section's own prose. | Confirmed. The count moves with each save and the invariant does not — which is why §13.5 publishes the invariant and labels the tally. |
 +| Verified the four published listings against the committed files by extracting them from the **rendered** page. | ''alexa_date_audit_mutations.sh'', both ''*-output.txt'' byte-identical; ''alexa_date_audit.mjs'' identical after stripping trailing whitespace (DokuWiki pads blank lines inside a ''%%<file>%%'' block with one space). 186 lines, 0 non-whitespace differences. |
  
 === Pass 4 — generic, no checklist (Claude Fable) === === Pass 4 — generic, no checklist (Claude Fable) ===
Line 761: Line 767:
  
 [[design:website_selection|← back to the content page]] · [[provenance:design:longitudinal|the longitudinal amendment this prompted]] · [[literature:corpus|corpus-level provenance]] [[design:website_selection|← back to the content page]] · [[provenance:design:longitudinal|the longitudinal amendment this prompted]] · [[literature:corpus|corpus-level provenance]]
 +
 +===== Markup sweep, 2026-09-17 =====
 +
 +Mechanical rendering repair only: a fresh live raw/XHTML export of 188 pages was checked with ''check_wrap.mjs'' and ''check_typography.mjs''. Affected plugin tags, CLI flags and heading markup were repaired; no figures or substantive prose were changed. The resulting source and rendered DOM were re-checked after saving.
 +
 +===== Link-hygiene sweep, 2026-09-17 =====
 +
 +The paired content page's two bare ''Artifacts'' links are now root-anchored after the fresh rendered-DOM sweep confirmed they had resolved to ''design:artifacts''. The post-save DOM was re-checked for red links. No figures or citations changed.
  
provenance/design/website_selection.1788468473.txt.gz · Last modified: by karel.kubicek.claude