| Both sides previous revisionPrevious revision | |
| design:ip_classification [2026/08/12 10:05] – Review pass (Fable): fix stale figures that sat OUTSIDE the corpus section and so were missed by the windowed staleness guard. Intro 234/92/53 -> 295/114/68; operator prefix-list grep six -> seven of 5,859; abuse-feed count 13 of 234 -> 17 of 295; the NDS karel.kubicek.claude | design:ip_classification [2026/08/12 15:45] (current) – Methodology section: replaced the generic corpus caveats (absent venues, provisional 2025-2026) with a pointer to the new literature:corpus page, keeping the page-specific consequence. Authored by Claude. karel.kubicek.claude |
|---|
| * **Folding.** ''scripts/ip_fold.mjs'' maps 443 distinct free-text names onto ordered regex families, specific products before the generic term they contain, and returns anything unmatched. Residue is zero and is printed on every run — but it was **18 strings** when the corpus grew to 2026 and had to be extended; see [[provenance:design:ip_classification]] for what was added and where each new string went. The families are ours, not the papers': ''Other IP blocklists'' merges a dozen services that are not interchangeable. | * **Folding.** ''scripts/ip_fold.mjs'' maps 443 distinct free-text names onto ordered regex families, specific products before the generic term they contain, and returns anything unmatched. Residue is zero and is printed on every run — but it was **18 strings** when the corpus grew to 2026 and had to be extended; see [[provenance:design:ip_classification]] for what was added and where each new string went. The families are ours, not the papers': ''Other IP blocklists'' merges a dozen services that are not interchangeable. |
| * **Field stability.** The enums (''method'', ''validation'', ''target'') are reproducible on a repeat extraction to within a few points. Free-text resource names are ~20% stable by exact string, which is why they appear here only as folded rankings. | * **Field stability.** The enums (''method'', ''validation'', ''target'') are reproducible on a repeat extraction to within a few points. Free-text resource names are ~20% stable by exact string, which is why they appear here only as folded rankings. |
| * **Venue coverage.** EuroS&P, ACSAC, RAID, AsiaCCS, CHI and SOUPS are absent, as are the venues where much of this work actually appears — **PAM, TMA, ANRW, SIGCOMM and ACM CCR are not in the corpus**, and for IP geolocation specifically that is a serious gap. Any claim here is a claim about seven venues. | * **Venue coverage.** Seven venues only — the scope and the selection funnel are on [[literature:corpus]]. For //this// topic the venues where much of the work actually appears are all absent: **PAM, TMA, ANRW, SIGCOMM and ACM CCR are not in the corpus**, and for IP geolocation specifically that is a serious gap. |
| * **The corpus reaches 2026, but its last two years are provisional.** CCS and IMC 2026 have not been held and two more 2026 venue-years are incompletely selected, so a per-period row ending in 2025–2026 rests on fewer papers than a complete window would give. The "current in 2026" judgements on this page are ours, checked against vendor and standards documentation, not derived from the corpus. | * **The corpus reaches 2026, but its last two years are provisional** (see [[literature:corpus]]), so a per-period row ending in 2025–2026 rests on fewer papers than a complete window would give. The "current in 2026" judgements on this page are ours, checked against vendor and standards documentation, not derived from the corpus. |
| * **Every query behind this section, the report script and its unedited output** are on [[provenance:design:ip_classification]]; corpus-level caveats are on [[literature:corpus]]. | * **Every query behind this section, the report script and its unedited output** are on [[provenance:design:ip_classification]]; corpus-level caveats are on [[literature:corpus]]. |
| |
